June 26, 2012

New op-ed on Fisher v. University of Texas

By Joshua P. Thompson Senior Attorney

I joined with Roger Clegg, President of the Center for Equal Opportunity on this op-ed that was published in the Christian Science Monitor last week.  Here’s a snippet:

At one time, affirmative action was designed to benefit African Americans recently subjected to Jim Crow, over whites who had been the segregated system’s beneficiaries. But now, more and more, it is Asians (our fastest growing ethnic group) who are discriminated against in favor of Latinos (our largest minority). At the University of Texas, for instance, in 2009, admitted Asians had an average SAT score 197 points higher than the average score for admitted Hispanics.

What’s the historical justification for that difference?

As for the “diversity” rationale, it is becoming more and more problematic to justify using race and ethnicity as a proxy for people’s perspectives and experiences – or to identify students from disadvantaged backgrounds. There are of course many white and Asian students who come from disadvantaged backgrounds, and many African Americans and Latinos who do not.

Read the rest.  Also, thanks to Yahoo! for picking this up.

What to read next