Victory in Decker: Supreme Court says NPDES permits not required for logging road runoff
The U.S. Supreme Court issued its opinion this morning in Decker v. Northwest Environmental Defense Center. In a 7-1 decision, written by Justice Kennedy, the Court concluded that EPA’s Industrial Stormwater Rule exempts discharges of channeled stormwater runoff from logging roads from the NPDES permitting scheme. The Court’s opinion is based on its conclusion that EPA’s regulation is a reasonable interpretation of the Clean Water Act provision requiring permits for discharges “associated with industrial activity.” EPA has consistently interpreted the CWA to exempt stormwater discharges from logging roads, and the Court’s decision today upholds that interpretation.
The opinion is consistent with PLF’s amicus briefs in this case.
Stay tuned for a follow-up post analyzing the opinion in greater detail.
What to read next
Shed a (crocodile) tear for Luke Skywalker today, as Mark Hamill’s much ballyhooed Autograph Law is set to be undone and reformed by the same California officials who made the mistake to pass it in the first place. AB 228 has arrived at the Governor’s desk, and in all likelihood will be signed into law any day.
Our new flagship publication, Sword&Scales, offers 16 pages of news and information to bring you up close to the vital work of our legal team. Our ardent defense of the right to own and use private property takes center stage in the inaugural issue. It’s at the core of our mission in the nation’s courts.
On Thursday, in Minnesota Voters Alliance v. Mansky, PLF filed this reply brief in support of its cert petition to the Supreme Court of the United States. In this case, we’re representing Minnesota voters in a First Amendment challenge to a ban on political apparel at polling places.
The Daily Journal published my column on California Cannabis Coalition v. City of Upland, recently decided by the California Supreme Court. As the op-ed points out, the ruling undermines Proposition 218’s requirements that all new taxes at the local level need voter approval.