Environmental citizen suits—abused and unconstitutional

November 16, 2026 | By SYDNEY MADIGAN

Last month, Pacific Legal Foundation attorneys and researchers participated in the Mercatus Center’s Markets & Society conference—a gathering attended by economists, attorneys, policymakers, and more. PLF staff showcased the groundbreaking work of our litigators and researchers, highlighting our passion for liberty and individual rights.

One conference presentation focused on the work of our new Environment and Natural Resources practice group, whose focus is litigating to unleash human ingenuity that solves environmental issues and builds a brighter future. The presentation particularly detailed PLF’s recent litigation—and wins!— in challenges to environmental citizen suits. Under major environmental laws like the Clean Water Act and the Clean Air Act, private individuals (or more often, special interest groups) can sue Americans for alleged violations of these federal environmental laws. Although likely enacted by Congress with the best of intentions, these suits have been wildly abused and weaponized against Americans, their businesses, and their communities.

Take, for instance, the case of Amsted Graphite Materials, a graphite manufacturing company based in rural Anmoore, West Virginia. In addition to continuing its century-long tradition of producing graphite materials, Amsted was upgrading its facility to reduce its environmental impact and working with the Environmental Protection Agency and the West Virginia Department of Environmental Protection to find new ways to protect the environment. But its pursuit of innovation was forced to a screeching halt when two special interest groups filed an environmental citizen suit against Amsted, alleging that the company violated the Clean Water Act.

Businesses like Amsted have two options when facing a citizen suit: spend copious money, time, and resources fighting the allegations in court, or settle the case with the suing party. This dichotomy is the first failure of the environmental citizen suit method: Because violations of environmental legislation carry a hefty per-day fine, accused Americans are highly incentivized to simply settle the case.

The catch? The money from a settlement often doesn’t go to the government, as the civil fines for violations would if the case was concluded in court. Rather, the money can go to a third party—which, many times, ends up going to a project affiliated with the suing party. As long as the group filing the citizen suit offers to settle for less than the sued party would pay if convicted in court, the suing party has a high chance of successfully settling.

This incentive structure is inherently unfair. It places all of the power—and the financial incentives—in the hands of the suing party.

And that’s not the end of the incentive problems with environmental citizen suits. These suits can be weaponized by special interest groups in a way that doesn’t even address any environmental concerns, but instead go after paperwork errors—a far cry from what the authors of the environmental citizen suit likely envisioned. PLF is involved in just such a case—where our clients, a family-run clay supply company, was sued by two special interest groups for alleged violations of the Clean Water Act. After eight years of litigation, the groups are still pushing their suit forward—even though the only harms alleged now are paperwork violations. And these groups can pursue attorney fees, as well—even though it’s nearly impossible for the defendants to recover theirs if they win the case.

And the intrinsic problems of the environmental citizen suit don’t end there: The method is also fraught with constitutional issues. As detailed by PLF attorneys in case filings, these suits offend constitutional protections in multiple ways.

First, environmental citizen suit plaintiffs wield presidential power, but without any checks on that power. When the president directs the prosecution of an alleged crime, he is cabined by various checks on his power—if he over- or under-enforces a law, his actions are checked by the voters via elections. But not so with the private suer in a citizen suit. Unlike the president, whose power is penned in by the legislative and judicial branches, as well as by elections, the actions of plaintiffs in citizen suits are totally unmonitored by another body—let alone the American electorate. The constitutional protections that keep prosecutions fair and impartial are nowhere to be found in the environmental citizen suit, where the plaintiffs don’t face the guardrails that keep the president’s actions in check.

Additionally, environmental citizen suits steal the executive branch’s jurisdiction over prosecuting a suit. The Framers placed the power for how to prosecute a law in the executive’s hands. But the environmental citizen suit forces the president to prosecute cases that he may be ill-equipped to manage efficiently. In days of backlogged and understaffed agencies, the president should allocate resources to address society’s biggest problems first. If his attention and resources are forced away from that, then Americans are left without attention to their everyday needs, while special interest groups pocket money from exploiting sue-and-settle tactics.

This is just the tip of the iceberg of the problems with the environmental citizen suit. But American businesses like Amsted are fighting back, challenging these suits in court, represented free of charge by PLF attorneys. PLF is hopeful that the intrinsic flaws of environmental citizen suits will encourage courts to shelve this vehicle in favor of methods that preserve Americans’ constitutional protections and empower businesses and individuals alike to move toward environmentalism rooted in innovation and human ingenuity, rather than red tape and fear.

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

CASES AND COMMENTARY IN THE FIGHT FOR FREEDOM. SENT TO YOUR INBOX.

Subscribe to the weekly Docket for dispatches from the front lines.