Active: Petition asks Supreme Court to apply the Seventh Amendment’s jury trial guarantee to the states

When a federal agency accuses someone of securities fraud and seeks to punish them with fines, the Constitution guarantees them a jury. The U.S. Supreme Court settled that question in SEC v. Jarkesy, a 2024 case holding that the Seventh Amendment requires a jury trial when the Securities and Exchange Commission seeks civil penalties for fraud. In such cases, a jury of one’s peers, not the agency bringing the charges, decides whether the government has proved its claims.

But the Seventh Amendment has never been incorporated against the states, meaning its jury guarantee does not apply when a state agency brings charges. The same claims and penalties can therefore lead to two very different proceedings: Face securities fraud charges from a federal agency, and your case will be heard by a jury; face the same charges from a state agency, and a government official can decide the case alone.

Swan Energy, a company that partners with investors on oil and gas projects, and three of its officials found themselves on the wrong side of that line in 2020, when Delaware’s Investor Protection Unit accused them of securities fraud and offering or selling unregistered securities in violation of the state securities laws. It sought fines and other penalties against them. The State brought its case to a hearing officer appointed by the attorney general, whose office was also prosecuting the case. Juries play no role in this process.

Juries matter especially in securities fraud cases. The cases often turn on disputed issues of fact, and it is very easy for the government to characterize defendants as guilty until proven innocent. The Constitution requires juries to serve as a check on government. Without them, grave injustices can occur in hard cases. When Swan Energy asked Delaware’s courts for a jury, the Delaware Supreme Court refused, noting that Jarkesy does not bind the states because the Seventh Amendment is not incorporated against them.

Represented by Pacific Legal Foundation and Dean Elwell of McCarter & English, Swan Energy asks the U.S. Supreme Court to change that.

Justice Neil Gorsuch has already signaled the Court should take up the question. When the justices declined to hear a jury trial challenge to civil fines in Humboldt County, California, in October 2025, he wrote that “surely, those who founded our Nation considered the right to trial by jury a fundamental part of their birthright,” “so much so that they cited its deprivation at the hands of colonial authorities as one of the reasons for breaking ties with England.” He added that the “Court should confront its Seventh Amendment holding soon. A right ‘of such importance,’ one that ‘occupies so firm a place in our history,’ deserves no less.”

A ruling for Swan Energy would guarantee every American the right to make their case to a jury before the government penalizes them, whether the charges come from a federal agency or a state one.

What’s At Stake?

  • The Seventh Amendment’s jury trial guarantee has never been applied to the states. The U.S. Supreme Court should incorporate that protection so every American—regardless of where they live—can demand that the government prove its case to a jury before it can punish them.

Case Timeline

November 13, 2026
This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

CASES AND COMMENTARY IN THE FIGHT FOR FREEDOM. SENT TO YOUR INBOX.

Subscribe to the weekly Docket for dispatches from the front lines.