This morning, the Supreme Court declined to hear the case of Pacific Legal Foundation client, Dr. Azadeh Khatibi. Dr. Khatibi, an ophthalmologist who was joined in her suit by the late Dr. Marilyn Singleton, an anesthesiologist, and the national medical advocacy organization, Do No Harm, challenged California’s 2019 mandate, AB 241. Under the mandate, all continuing medical education (CME) courses involving direct patient care are required to incorporate implicit bias into their training. Implicit bias is the idea that medical professionals unconsciously treat patients differently based on their race or other immutable characteristics. This requirement stands regardless of who teaches the course or what is being taught.
Medical professionals are required to take CME courses to stay current on medical research, emerging treatments, and developments in their fields. The implicit-bias requirement forces instructors to take time away from teaching relevant information and provide “examples of,” or “strategies” to prevent, disparate health outcomes as a result of implicit bias.
Dr. Khatibi would be fine with implicit-bias training if it were voluntary. But as a CME instructor, she is now forced to espouse views she finds unsupported by evidence and far afield from her expertise. Worse, she is required to devote already limited course time to this divisive topic.
“For the government to tell doctors what they can and cannot teach to other doctors is really frightening to me,” she warns. “Not saying what you would have taught because you are forced by law to teach something else changes both medical education and the practice of medicine. The State should not be involved in what is taught and not taught in medicine.”
Dr. Khatibi filed a lawsuit challenging California’s attempt to suppress free expression and force ideological compliance of preferred viewpoints.
When the case reached the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals, the court held that California’s implicit-bias-training requirement constitutes government speech, rather than compelled private speech, and as such, was not subject to First Amendment protections.
The Ninth Circuit’s decision relied on a 2022 Supreme Court case, Shurtleff v. Boston, that identified three factors for distinguishing government speech from private speech—history, public perception, and government control. Guided by Shurtleff, the Ninth Circuit reasoned that because California has a long history of regulating the medical profession so extensively, including CME training, the implicit-bias instruction qualifies as government speech even when private instructors deliver it.
Pacific Legal Foundation then asked the Supreme Court to hear the case and reconsider the Ninth Circuit ruling. Unfortunately, the Court declined, leaving the lower court’s ruling intact.
While this is unfortunate news for PLF’s clients, Justice Clarence Thomas’ dissent offers a powerful defense of the constitutional issues at stake.
In his dissent, joined by Justice Samuel Alito, Justice Thomas expressed his concern that the Ninth Circuit’s ruling allows California to transform private speech into government speech simply by regulating it. In the process, the ruling shields compelled speech from First Amendment scrutiny. As Justice Thomas explains, “First Amendment protections do not give way simply because a State heavily regulates speech.”
He went on to say, “The government-speech doctrine occupies a narrow corner of our First Amendment jurisprudence. The First Amendment protects the people’s right of free speech against government interference; it does not prevent the government from speaking for itself.”
Justice Thomas also asks whether the government is speaking or regulating private expression. To this question, he says: “When, as here, the government does not issue its own messages but instead requires private speakers to communicate the government’s viewpoint, the First Amendment applies.”
But the Ninth Circuit’s ruling treats California’s role in regulating medical education as sufficient in categorizing privately delivered training as government speech. As Justice Thomas points out, “It cannot be the case that compelled speech becomes government speech because the government has compelled the speech.”
Justice Thomas argues that the Ninth Circuit focused too much of its decision on the breadth of California’s regulatory authority over healthcare. “In its blinkered application of the Shurtleff factors, the Ninth Circuit lost sight of the core government-speech inquiry.”
Justice Thomas explains that the Court failed to consider “‘the identity of the speaker,’” which is “‘[t]he ultimate question’ in the government-speech inquiry.”
But there is another area of concern for Justice Thomas. “More troubling than the Ninth Circuit’s misapplication of the Shurtleff factors,” he says, “are the implications of the Court’s decision.”
He worries that this sets a dangerous precedent, and he introduces a few hypotheticals, including: “At the next statewide legal conference at which lectures are offered for continuing legal education, could California require a keynote speaker to oppose racial preferences in law firm hiring?”
He goes on to caution that “Applying the Ninth Circuit’s logic, enough government regulation of the field would convert the private speaker’s message in each of these hypotheticals into government speech unprotected by the First Amendment.”
Justice Thomas’ concerns are not limited to how the Ninth Circuit applied the Shurtleff test, but also to the test itself.
In Shurtleff, Justices Thomas, Alito, and Neil Gorsuch warned in their concurrence that the Shurtleff framework could confuse government control over speech with government authorship of speech. In considering Khatibi, Justice Thomas added, “After only a few years, those concerns are materializing.”
He then makes a bold conclusion: “If the Ninth Circuit’s decision is truly the kind of result that Shurtleff’s three-factor test countenances, we should reconsider Shurtleff.”
In what might be the strongest line in his dissent and sums up the most problematic aspect of the Ninth Circuit’s ruling, Justice Thomas writes, “A State cannot regulate its way out of First Amendment scrutiny.”
While Justice Gorsuch joined Justices Thomas and Alito in expressing that he would have granted certiorari, he did not join Justice Thomas’ dissent.
When Dr. Khatibi was a young girl, her family left their lives behind in Iran to flee its government’s oppressive behavior, like restricting free speech. “I was born in Iran when we had the Iranian Revolution and the government was telling people what to do and what to say,” she recalls. “I thought that was all behind me, but now I know better.”
It seems fitting that her first name means “freedom.” Unfortunately, the Supreme Court’s decision means her challenge to California’s implicit bias training in CME training courses has ended without the resolution she had hoped for.
But PLF remains committed to the broader constitutional fight.
“While it’s disappointing for our clients, we’re encouraged that there is support on the Court to review this issue,” said Caleb Trotter, a senior attorney with Pacific Legal Foundation. “We’ll continue working to make sure doctors never have to surrender their free speech rights to keep their medical licenses.”