Rhode Island family wins eminent domain victory, but the fight continues

November 20, 2026 | By BRITTANY HUNTER

Like the rest of the country, Rhode Island is in the thick of an affordable housing crisis. With such a desperate need for new housing, you would think officials in the small town of Johnston would eagerly welcome new opportunities. But that doesn’t appear to be the case. Just ask the Santoro family.

Ralph Santoro and his childhood friend Salvatore “Sal” Compagnone own and operate a property management business, together with Ralph’s wife Suzanne and his sister Lucille.

The Santoros and Sal have always aimed to keep their rental rates far below market level to give individuals and families who may not have a lot, or are just starting out, the opportunity to have a nice home.

Around 1985, the group, which was started by their fathers, bought property in town and, over time, slowly started buying the surrounding property with the hopes of turning it into safe and affordable rental property. But for nearly 40 years, the Town of Johnston has fought them every step of the way,

In 2024, the State of Rhode Island announced that it would streamline the approval process for the development of new affordable housing statewide. Sal and the Santoros saw this as a great opportunity to finally start building a 252-unit complex on their property that would help Johnston mitigate its housing shortage by providing more affordable housing options. They began the process right away.

Given the dire need and the fact that as far back as 2004, the Town’s Comprehensive Community Plan had identified the property as a prime spot to add new affordable housing, the Santoros and Sal were surprised when the Town’s mayor, Joseph Polisena Jr., declared war on their plans. Mayor Polisena publicly vowed to “use all the power of government that I have to stop it.” He added that if the family instead agreed to build less-affordable, suburban-style residences, then “the Town w[ould] roll out the red carpet to guide you through the planning process and see the project to completion.”

The Santoros and Sal were shocked, but they had no intention of backing down or making any changes to their building plans. For his part, Mayor Polisena stayed true to his word.

The mayor claimed that the property in question was needed for a new municipal complex that would house government buildings, like a new police and fire station, even though his own words point to the real reason for the land grab: to stop the Santoros’ housing project.

Moreover, there are specific steps a government must take before exercising the drastic and one-sided power of eminent domain, none of which were honored.

Johnston voters reject expanded eminent domain power

After the Town took the property, the Santoro family filed a lawsuit in March 2025. In July 2026, the federal district court in Rhode Island ruled in favor of the Santoros, concluding that the Town’s charter did not give it the authority to take the land.

But Mayor Joseph Polisena Jr. refused to give up his fight and publicly pledged that “the Town will continue its pursuit of a much-needed municipal complex on the land,” identifying two possible routes: a municipal public buildings authority or a charter amendment granting the Town eminent domain authority. Town officials then sought to amend the charter and acquire that power through a ballot measure.

On Election Day, Johnston voters rejected the proposed charter amendment, with 53.74% voting no.

Despite the election results, the Town is continuing to pursue the Santoros’ land through the alternative route suggested by the mayor, a municipal public buildings authority. As a result, the Santoro family’s legal challenge is not over yet.

The Constitution protects the rights of property owners. And the government cannot take property through eminent domain simply because it doesn’t like an owner’s lawful use. Pacific Legal Foundation will continue to help the Santoro family and Sal as they fight for their property rights.

Photo by Richard Schultz

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

CASES AND COMMENTARY IN THE FIGHT FOR FREEDOM. SENT TO YOUR INBOX.

Subscribe to the weekly Docket for dispatches from the front lines.