The Docket: October 16, 2026

October 16, 2026 | By PLF

The Docket is PLF’s weekly newsletter covering the cases, clients, and policy battles shaping the future of liberty in America. You can catch up on last week’s Docket here and subscribe below to receive future editions in your inbox.

 


A broad coalition of California farmers, ranchers, and businesses challenges an “occupied critical habitat” designation for a nonexistent fish population; a Florida veteran takes on the State’s race- and sex-based quota for public service; and audiologists fight a Medicare rule that limits patient choice.

 

California farmers and ranchers challenge agency overreach declaring dry riverbed a critical steelhead habitat

Sound environmental policy should encourage both healthy ecosystems and the productive use of land to provide food, jobs, and opportunity. But too often, that balance is off kilter. Take California’s Santa Maria River, for example.

The best available evidence shows the Southern California steelhead left the river in the 1940s. Yet the federal government still classifies it as “occupied critical habitat”—imposing substantial restrictions on the people who work and invest there, all in the name of a nonexistent fish population.

Last week, local farmers, ranchers, and business groups partnered with PLF to petition the National Marine Fisheries Service to follow both the evidence and the law by rescinding the Santa Maria River from the steelhead’s “occupied critical habitat” designation.

Read More

 

Good enough for Google, but not for college? One student’s fight against discriminatory admissions

What does it take to earn a place at one of America’s top universities? On paper, Bay Area high school student Stanley Zhong seemed like a textbook shoo-in for admission to any of the schools on his short list. But as Stanley and his family would soon discover, being qualified for admission and getting admitted into college are not necessarily the same thing.

Read More

 

Audiologists fight Medicare rule denying professional freedom and patient choice

Medicare is a government-funded health insurance program and the primary health insurance for Americans 65 and older. Providers bill Medicare for the covered services they provide, follow its compliance rules, and accept the rates it sets.

Opting out of Medicare frees providers from the program’s billing hurdles, paperwork, and payment limits—allowing patients to pay directly for care from the professional they choose. Federal law permits a long list of healthcare professionals to opt out of the program, but audiologists are among the few excluded—in direct violation of the Constitution’s guarantees of equal protection and due process.

Earlier this week, PLF attorneys filed a federal lawsuit challenging that exclusion on behalf of the Academy of Doctors of Audiology (ADA), current ADA president Dr. Jill Davis, and fellow audiologist and former ADA president Dr. Alicia Spoor.

Read More

 

Government by guidance: How nonbinding agency documents become binding in practice

Government guidance documents are supposed to be merely nonbinding interpretations or policy statements, but PLF’s latest research report shows that they have become a major tool for shaping federal policy.

While guidance can serve an important role when it helps the public understand existing laws and agencies’ interpretations, when agencies use guidance to impose new legal obligations—bypassing constitutional lawmaking and formal rulemaking—they undermine transparency, accountability, and the rule of law.

Restoring guidance to its proper, nonbinding function would ensure that binding requirements are created only through the lawful processes required by Congress and the separation of powers.

Read More

 

Florida attorney challenges race- and sex-based barriers to public service

Stanley Cary Gaylord is an Army veteran and accomplished attorney who has spent decades defending Florida property owners’ constitutional rights.

Seeking to further his public service, Stanley explored joining Florida’s Statewide Judicial Nominating Commission for Judges of Compensation Claims. But he soon learned that state law reserves multiple Commission seats for “[members] of a minority group”—leaving him at a steep disadvantage solely due to his race and sex.

Earlier this week, with PLF’s help, Stanley filed a lawsuit challenging Florida’s quota system as a violation of the Constitution’s Equal Protection Clause, arguing that public service should be open to every qualified Floridian on equal terms.

Read More

 


Subscribe to PLF’s weekly newsletter, The Docket, to receive future updates in your inbox.

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

CASES AND COMMENTARY IN THE FIGHT FOR FREEDOM. SENT TO YOUR INBOX.

Subscribe to the weekly Docket for dispatches from the front lines.