Since the beginning of the COVID-19 pandemic, governors and mayors have been governing unilaterally under the guise of emergency powers. State legislatures and courts have failed to reassert their constitutional roles as co-equal branches of government.
It’s time for legislators and judges to end indefinite one-person rule.
Most states give their governors extraordinary powers in an emergency to protect the public’s health and safety when there is no time for legislative action. These emergency powers may be crucial in uncertain times, including pandemics, but their use must be time-limited and respectful of constitutional rights.
Unlimited, dictatorial rule cannot be allowed to continue indefinitely.
PLF is working with legislatures and in courtrooms across the country to place safeguards on emergency powers and restore constitutional government.
PLF’s model bill, the Emergency Power Limitation Act, provides for three main limits on the use of emergency powers. 1) Emergency orders will expire after a short period of time unless the state legislature extends them, 2) Emergency orders must be narrowly tailored to protect the public’s health and safety, rather than arbitrary and logically inconsistent, 3) Courts must provide expedited review of disputed orders that restrict constitutional rights.
316 million Americans across 42 states lived under stay-at-home orders in response to COVID-19. Unemployment has skyrocketed because of business closures, with unemployment highest in states with more severe shutdown orders. Travel is restricted. Nearly every aspect of life has changed.
Although emergencies may require swift, initial responses from an executive official, time allows legislators to fulfill their constitutional duty as the people’s representatives who make law, and for courts to constrain the worst abuses of power.
The separation of powers framework in our state and federal constitutions is the most important protection of individual liberty. Constitutional checks and balances should not be tossed aside, even in an emergency.
Principled reforms that reinforce separation of powers should include requirements that emergency orders:
Read more on PLF’s Recommendations for Principled Reform
Dr. Drew talks to Joe Luppino-Esposito, the deputy legal policy director at Pacific Legal Foundation and discusses how executive orders and emergency powers enable unelected government agencies to byp…
Supreme Court Justice Neil Gorsuch highlights a vital lesson from the COVID-19 pandemic.
Frustrated by a Congress that can’t or won’t accede to their preferred policies, presidents turn to executive orders and executive agencies to achieve their goals.
Arbitrary government has no place in our constitutional order. Yet many of today’s most significant federal policies reflect blatant abuses of presidential discretion.
If we’ve learned anything in the past few years, it’s that emergency power is easily abused. During the COVID-19 pandemic, governors across the country claimed unprecedented power to combat the vi…
In March 2020, California Gov. Gavin Newsom declared a statewide public health emergency in response to the COVID-19 pandemic, allowing him to issue lockdown orders and close businesses however he saw…
In Prohibition, this short documentary film from the Pacific Legal Foundation, Goodwood Brewing Company CEO Ted Mitzlaff and others explain how small businesses have been destroyed by governors’ con…
Crystal Waldron and Club 519 were shuttered for almost a year due to economic favoritism. She suffered through six months of discriminatory treatment — watching former customers have drinks at her d…
During the COVID-19 pandemic, former New York Governor Andrew Cuomo was breathlessly heralded as “the politician of the moment” and the “authoritative voice in the crisis.” His press briefings…
Presidents of both parties wrongly have expanded the unilateral executive policy playbook, but President Biden and House Speaker Nancy Pelosi (D-Calif.) are still teaching a master class in unaccounta…
2023 was a particularly big year for Pacific Legal Foundation. We celebrated our 50th birthday, which gave us the opportunity to reflect on moments that made PLF what we are today. Since 1973, we have had the privilege of changing lives: We’ve helped our clients challenge unjust government actions in the court of law and …
Every presidential administration reaches a point where the president is tempted to take lawmaking matters into his own hands. “I’ve got a pen and I’ve got a phone,” Barack Obama famously put it. Frustrated by a Congress that can’t or won’t accede to their preferred policies, presidents turn to executive orders and executive agencies to …
DECEMBER 30, 2020, afternoon Most people were packing up their offices. It was nearly New Year’s Eve of an election year at the Health and Human Services (HHS) offices in Washington, DC. Regardless of the skullduggery that goes on there, DC is beautiful around the holidays. Congress is out, so the streets and sideways are …
Unmasked and open for business, the world is increasingly prepared to move on from the pandemic. But our world certainly has not returned to normal. Our reality is, unfortunately, still defined by constant crisis: viruses, shocking violence, rampant inflation, and war. Government response to these crises hasn’t deviated much from the COVID …
There is a legal reckoning on the horizon. At the height of the COVID-19 pandemic, state and local governments delegated an extraordinary amount of power to unelected public health officials. Now, two and a half years into the pandemic, the public is still grappling with the consequences of this unprecedented transfer of power from elected …
The pandemic was hard on all small businesses in North Carolina, but perhaps most of all on “private bars”—an antiquated classification of bars in North Carolina from the prohibition era. An establishment is considered a private bar if it makes 75% or more of its profit from alcohol sales. When Rob and Crystal Waldron reached …
When a great crisis visits the nation, the niceties of constitutionally protected rights must take a holiday. Only later, once the crisis has resolved, can we go about deciding which rights should be fully restored, and which rights should be modified to meet the new circumstances of a post-crisis world. Rights, after all, must give …
The California legislature has passed revolutionary legislation in the past few years that makes it easier for residents to build additional housing in the form of accessory dwelling units (ADUs), more recognizable to some as granny flats, basement apartments, or small backyard cottages. These new reforms, which remove costly and complicated barrie …
As the COVID-19 pandemic gradually recedes from the highs we saw in 2020, we should carefully reflect on what the past 15 months of a public health emergency have taught us. As a longtime advocate for individual liberty and limited government, here’s the principal lesson I take from our pandemic experience: The separation of governmental …
Located in downtown Louisville, Goodwood Brewing Company is one of the largest breweries in Kentucky. In 2019, it produced some 10,000 barrels (248,000 pints) of beer for sale in its taprooms and for distribution to 16 states. In March of 2020, the state forced Goodwood Brewery to close its doors for on-site consumption when the …
Help us end the practice of unilateral governance under the guise of emergency powers.
