In the mid-1960s, Arthur and Betty Lujan bought submerged land in the Florida Keys from the State of Florida. Their company, Key Haven Associated Enterprises, won approval for 151 residential lots and began dredging canals, filling in the land, and building roads and homes.
The State had approved the plans. Then the State changed its mind.
After the Legislature passed new environmental laws in the early 1970s, state officials halted the work in 1973, with 19 lots still undeveloped. In 1986, Monroe County amended its plan to allow no housing density on land designated as mangroves.
Key Haven kept working within the system. In 2007, it protected nine other lots with a conservation easement. In 2018, it applied to the Florida Department of Environmental Protection for permits to dredge and fill five of the remaining lots. The department said no. An administrative law judge agreed, and the department issued a final denial.
Key Haven sued, arguing the government had effectively taken the five lots by barring any use of them without paying just compensation. A Leon County court ruled the lawsuit came too late. It said the four-year deadline to sue started in the early 1970s or 1980s—decades before Key Haven applied for a permit. In August 2026, Florida’s First District Court of Appeal agreed.
That ruling conflicts with other Florida appeals courts, which say the deadline to sue starts only after the government gives a final answer on the owner’s application. It also conflicts with the Florida Supreme Court’s own 1982 ruling in an earlier Key Haven case, which required the company to finish the state’s review process before suing over a permit denial. Under the First District’s approach, owners can follow every step and then learn the deadline passed decades ago. The U.S. Supreme Court warned against that result in Palazzolo v. Rhode Island (which PLF argued before the Court), saying a state may not put “an expiration date on the Takings Clause.”
Represented at no cost by Pacific Legal Foundation, Key Haven is asking the Florida Supreme Court to hear the case and rule that the deadline to sue starts no earlier than the government’s final decision on the owner’s application.
A win would protect every Florida property owner who plays by the permit rules and would keep the Constitution’s promise of just compensation from expiring before owners can claim it.