Represented at no cost by Pacific Legal Foundation, the Town of Alexandria asks the court to dismiss the citizen suit filed against it and find the CWA’s citizen suit provision unconstitutional.
Martelli’s argues that citizen suits threaten Americans’ rights by allowing private actors, who cannot be held accountable by the voting public, to exercise government authority.
Corona Clay argues that the CWA’s citizen suit provision should be struck down because it violates the Constitution’s nondelegation doctrine and the separation of powers by allowing private plaintiffs to wield the executive branch’s prosecutorial powers.
Representing coal producers across the state, the Kentucky Coal Association (KCA) partnered with Pacific Legal Foundation to intervene in the lawsuit in support of the rule's repeal.
The people with the greatest motivation to protect and maintain the areas impacted by the Roadless Rule are the communities and businesses who live and work there. Bureaucrats and agency officials should not be able to unilaterally prohibit them from accessing land that could otherwise provide opportunity, employment, and key resources to millions of Americans.
Kirsop put the question to the district directly: Why are you demanding permits from property owners who do not need a permit?
Californian farmers and ranchers should not be forced to shoulder the cost of federal agencies’ refusal to acknowledge decades of data. Every resident of the United States depends on the country’s farmers. When overreaching government policies drive up the cost of operating—or threaten the ability to farm at all—every American pays the price.
Rob Dunn bought 87 acres in Vermilion, Ohio, hoping to farm land that had long been designated for it. Instead, runoff from a road culvert floods his fields, woods, and front yard. When local officials refused to help, Rob placed fill to protect his home. Now Ohio EPA is suing him, claiming a seasonal low spot is a protected water. With PLF's help, Rob is fighting back.
The Bingham family has farmed in Bingham County, Idaho, since 1950. Today, the demands of a state agency threaten to destroy that legacy.